Persistent Psychological Warfare: Israel vs. Hamas!
Repetition Compulsion—IDF Intelligence Failure vs Syrian/Iran Rockets Delivered through Sudan, Qatar, Gaza and Egypt to Hamas!!
Major Israeli/Bibi Intelligence Failure---Once Again!
How many more Israeli Reservists must die for another Bibi Failure like 2012 Operation Pillar to eliminate Hamas Rockets? For the past week, the world has once again witnessed the perverse kabuki of IDF forces retaliating against Hamas rockets, this time targeting Tel Aviv, Haifa, Hadera and Hof HaCarmel. How did this happen and why?
First, let me say, that I am intimately familiar with the modest genius Uzi Rubin who had the foresight, wisdom and chutzpah to create the “Iron Dome” that is protecting Israelis from the horrible consequences of actual rocket attacks. The country would have been strewn with carnage far beyond anyone’s imagination had Uzi not convinced the Israeli political/military leadership decades ago to develop the “Iron Dome” to protect the country from foreseeable destruction. At the time of his inchoate suggestion, most of the Israeli leadership could not take Uzi’s ideas and plans very seriously. Yet, Uzi persisted and today, most Israelis are safe because of the courage and foresight of this modest Sabrah who not only fought bravely on the Golan Heights but had the intellectual skill and vision to prepare his homeland, Eretz Israel from future attacks.
I bring up his name because Uzi has always represented to me the best of Israel. He was born in Palestine at a famous settlement that his illustrious family had founded in Gedera, one of the original Zionist settlements before the state was created. He, like many of us, grew up a Likudnik, believing and following the precepts of Menachem Begin and Ze’ev Jabotinsky. But over time, Uzi had become one of the more brilliant scientists/operators in the Israeli Defense Establishment, sublimating his talents into productive defensive strategic operational systems.
Uzi, like many who had participated in terrorist acts as well as wars, understood that in order for Israel to survive as a mature country it needed ‘out-of-the-box’ thinking in war as well as in peace. Too bad Israel in total did not follow his course of transformation from warrior /operator to technical genius dedicated to the well-being of his homeland.
Israel has transformed itself over sixty years from a Polish-inspired dream of a few Zionists into a Hi Tech Phenomena, admired all over the world for its’ scientific innovations and humane contributions to the health care field. Unfortunately, the Israeli leadership failed to transform it’s old shetl ways of infighting, bickering, manipulations and deceit into a mature establishment where transition of elite power could be implemented without going to war against one another or a surrounding Arab country.
It was no accident that the father of the Likud/Herut parties and the model of terrorists around the Arab world—Menachem Begun, Leader of the Irgun Zve Leumi—was the first Prime Minister to accept President Jimmy Carter’s Camp David Peace Accords. With the encouragement of the brilliantly, talented one-eyed icon of Israeli military might—Gen. Moshe Dayan--- a peace treaty was implemented in which another terrorist—Awar Sadat—garnered peace for close to four decades.
Nor was it an accident that the mercurial, manipulative, blustering, self-aggrandizing Gen Ariel Sharon [Arik] singlehandedly ordered the withdrawal of Israeli forces from the west bank after having sacrificed his life and the countless thousands of Israeli soldiers lives to attain military victories in the Six Day War and Yom Kippur War.
What am I getting at?
These unusual warriors understood that war and military retaliations all had a very limited value.
As Arik once said: ”It is impossible to have a JEWISH, DEMOCRATIC STATE and AT THE SAME TIME CONTROL ALL OF ERETZ ISRAEL”. [my emphasis].
But he added these prophetic words:
“IF WE INSIST ON FULFILLING THE DREAM IN ITS ENTIRETY…. WE ARE LIABLE TO LOSE IT ALL!”
Back to my basic point about the IDF vs Hamas psychological warfare. The crux of Israel’s viability as a state is INTELLIGENCE. If the intelligence is poor in any particular area then the leaders of the country will rely on their innate instincts based on hubris, ignorance and worn weary habits of RETALIATION against the perceived enemy.
Why do I say perceived enemy?
Hamas was and is a complete creation of the IDF, Shin Bet, Mossad. When I was working on the West Bank in the late 1980’s for the State Dept with PLO physicians who were detained by the IDF with a British contrived nonsense called “preventive detention”, I was informed correctly that Shin Bet had created Hamas in Beir Zet in the Gaza as a counter-force for the PLO.
That was part and parcel of the Game of Terrorism. We, Americans created AL Qaeda then Haqqani et al. –all of which we are now trying to destroy. Like many western countries including the USA, Israel created Hamas as a strategic tension point to the PLO who were eventually driven out of Jordan by the Hashemite King Hussein into Lebanon.
Once Hamas became active and effectively neutralized the PLO, it turned against it’s creator the Israelis just like Frankenstein.
At one time, the Israelis maintained a very effective and ruthless Intelligence Corp to monitor this “Franken-Terrorist Group”. However, over time, as I had warned both the Israelis and the Americans; Israel had lost its INTELLIGENCE FORTE.
The reason was quite simple.
As Israel became increasingly more prosperous, thanks to the young geniuses creating start-ups and invaluable hi tech companies, the smarter and more creative individuals refused to enter the intelligence community, preferring to make a fortune with their expertise in the hi tech arena. In reality, Israel’s success as a HI TECH NATION HAS LED IT INTO A CONUNDRUM OF A FAULTY INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY AND AN EXCEEDINGLY VULNERABLE ARMY, CONSISTING MAINLY OF RESERVISTS WHO REALLY DO NOT WANT TO FIGHT ANY MORE WARS……
Today, Israel suffers from the “FAILURE OF SUCCESS”—as I have termed their maturation and vulnerability.
What can be done now?
[1] Dismiss all of the present intelligence directors of Mossad, Shin Bet, Zahal, et al. New ideas require new, fresh blood.
[2] Bibi must resign now or soon. He is not really a Sabrah. He is the story of boy who rode on his brother’s heroism [Entebbe Raid]; grew up in Pennsylvania; scion of an arrogant, obtuse Cornell Teacher [I knew him there].
[3] The mothers of IDF soldiers must go to the ministry and demand a DECLARATION of PEACE with all parties ---including Hamas. The mothers of IDF soldiers were instrumental in making peace with HEZBOLLAH, a far more formidable group than Hamas.
[4] Israel should become the KEYSTONE of TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENT in the Middle East—and share their technological know-how with Egypt, PLO, Syria, Lebanon, Qatar, Sudan, Saudi Arabia, Iran et al.
[5] Israel cannot and should not DEPEND ON THE USA. It has to learn that the American people are tired of fostering an artificial dependency with a country that should have matured a long time ago.
[6] Israel should forget the meaningless blustering rhetoric of the neocon Jews—Dennis Ross, Doug Feith, David Wormser, Martin Indyk [Australian intel operative and Ross henchman], Elliot Abrams, Richard Haas, Paul Wolfowitz. They have created more disasters in Iraq, Afghanistan, etc.
[7] Remember the Hebrew “CONCEPTZIYA”--- word coined after the Yom Kippur War in 1973, ‘to describe the BLIND ARROGANCE ‘ of invincibility.
As the former Scientist/President of Israel, Ephraim Katzir said, ”The hubris broadcast by the Labor Govt reflected the CORRUPTION OF THE NATIONAL ETHOS by DELUSIONS OF GRANDEUR in the wake of 1967 conquests.” [Landau].
I have personally and professionally worked with Sadat, Menachem Begun, Yitzhak Rabin, Shamir, Arafat, and many other operatives in the Middle East. If in thirty years, the Soviet Union could be transformed into a Russian Federation without war; and China could transform from a inefficient Communist/Maoist State into a thriving economic juggernaut; and Apartheid could be destroyed….. Please don’t tell me that ISRAEL cannot make peace with all of it’s neighbors! Even Hamas!!
What a shame on the Jewish People that we could create a state from nothing but sand, malaria and flies and then transform it back into a desolate state of carnage because we were too ‘stiff necked’ to bow our heads and extend our hands out in the gesture of peace and mutual trust.
It takes a very intelligent individual to understand that peace allows the national character of a state to evolve into a mature entity. Paranoia, fear, mistrust, arrogance are all the characteristics of IMMATURITY, INSOLENCE and…. SADLY BUT PROPHETICALLY …..SELF-DESTRUCTION!!!
If one Israeli soldiers enters into Gaza and tries to strip Hamas of their rockets, then Tel Aviv, Haifa, and then all of the Israeli cities will be set ablaze with the absolute precision of suicide bombers and terrorist tactics. Of that I am 100 % certain!
It’s up to you now, Israelis!
Peace? Or Self-Destruction! Your EXISTENTIAL CHOICE!!
And please don’t blame Obama, America, or anyone else!
It’s now up to the JEWISH PEOPLE of the JEWISH STATE!!!